Athlete: Derek Jeter
Status: Hall of Famer
A-Listers Dated: Jessica Biel, Vanessa Minnillo, Minka Kelly, Scarlett Johansson, Mariah Carey
Derek most recently swooped in to woo Minka, after she was ditched by John Mayer for Jennifer Aniston. The couple seem to be going strong still, as they were recently spotted at a University of Texas football game in October.
